For example, an IA must not only be integrated but also strategic and principle-based in order to be effective. We do not elaborate on criteria we feel adequately meet their respective intent or are appropriate in assessing sustainability as they currently stand. This provides both great freedom and difficulty for planners, designers, and policy makers in attempting to achieve SUD. As theories of IA previously discussed indicate, an integrated assessment requires a careful balance between quantitative and qualitative methodologies. Help Center Find new research papers in: See White for a more detailed historical account.
Guiding vision and goals, 2. Promote social equity by ensuring access to services that address the needs of a variety of economic classes. A guide for health, sustainability and vitality. Study Cambridge Science Park flashcards from ‘ This proposed assessment incorporates elements we find missing from LEED ND, includes new scoring calculations based on the weighting of points for relevant pillars, reconsiders the weighting of some credits and builds in flexibility in many of the criteria to consider urban developments in addition to peri- and sub-urban development. Put here purely to share with pupils.
The difficulty in achieving an evenly weighted assessment relates to the difficulty of addressing all three pillars in any single assessment at the project level, primarily because sustainability is an interscalar concept.
Case Study- Greenwich Millennium Villiage
Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, vol 19, no 2, p Preferred Location considers environmental, economic and social sustainability. This is because it is impossible to evaluate SUD in a vacuum without undertaking a value judgment associated with what constitutes SUD.
However, GMV is currently isolated from nearby transit and employment centers and offers distinctly different quality of housing to people of different tenures, undermining economic and social sustainability within the development.
In other words, they question the extent to which qualitative methodologies should inform assessment over quantitative methods. Gfography Critical Review and Analysis.
Not only is uneven consideration given to each pillar, but it is not transparent how credits contribute to different spheres. CoastsA case study of one …. However, because of the new prerequisite that a minimum of 25 points be achieved in each pillar, syudy development would not be certified.
For these reasons we looked outside the UK for a SA method that more fully reflects our view of SUD and what an assessment method should include within its scope if it is to properly facilitate true SUD. Put here purely to share with pupils.
Thank you to others for some of this work. However, we believe improvement can be made to the system of weighting and scoring within LEED ND, mostly by increasing transparency regarding the relevant pillar weightings.
Greenwich millennium village gcse geography case study
Diagrams reproduced from ‘geography In this regard SAs play a key role in creating a knowledge structure and vocabulary that allows society to assess progress towards sustainable development by measuring the sustainability of a building or development13 Aggregain a. There is a clear link between bodies involved in developing a SA and the emphasis of the assessment. This proposed assessment incorporates elements we find missing from LEED ND, includes new scoring calculations based on the weighting of points for relevant pillars, reconsiders the weighting of some credits and builds in flexibility in geographhy of the criteria to consider urban developments in addition to peri- and sub-urban development.
By Carmen Elena and Andrade Romero.
GCSE Geography Case Studies – Online Flashcards by Meg Daniel | Brainscape
Project analysis for each criteria results in one score per credit, which is then applied equally to each relevant pillar. For example, Smart Location caes Linkage — Credit 3. Case Study of GMV for changing land use.
In reviewing SA methods commonly used in the UK, e.
However, in our analysis of various credits comprising the assessment, we found it often has an implicit suburban — rather than urban — focus, likely influenced by the ideologies of the Congress for the New Urbanism. The principles include 10 categories14 that discuss the scope, clarity, content, and procedural application that should guide any sustainability assessment: United Nations Population Fund. LEED ND includes within its basic tenets an attempt to link the environmental, economic and social dimensions of a holistic view of sustainability.
For the most part, these methods fail to embrace a truly integrated assessment philosophy, which we feel is essential if a SA is to promote SUD. As theories of IA previously discussed indicate, an integrated assessment requires a careful balance between quantitative and qualitative methodologies. You could make a good case for any of You will need to know all of the case studies in this document.
Case Study- Greenwich Millennium Villiage – Presentation in GCSE Geography
Paradoxically, as cities contribute to many social and environmental problems, they are also seen as solutions to these same issues.
Current efforts to evaluate and improve the environmental impact of buildings contribute to environmental sustainability; however, we do not believe buildings can truly be called sustainable without consideration of the larger urban scale in which they are located9.
Definition of Sustainability An example of the difficulty associated with implementing SUD can be seen in the use of the term itself. Any assessment should ensure the participation of people who can contribute a qualitative voice to mainly quantitative assessment.
In many instances, such as the minimum affordable housing requirements, the UK and other European countries have higher social housing and diversity targets and a long history of related policies which should be incorporated into any such assessment as it is applied outside the US. LEED ND was originally chosen for this case study because it is unique in its scalar focus amongst existing SA tools and is intentionally concerned with the urban and neighborhood scales.